Start Easy. Creating perfectly balanced encounters takes practice. It’s better to err on the side of "too easy" than "too hard." As a GM, you have many ways to increase difficulty during play, but few ways to lower it without breaking immersion.
Fine Tuning Difficulty
GMG v1 p. 26
Related Rules
3Balancing With TacticsEncounters / Difficulty & Balance
Encounter DifficultiesEncounters / Difficulty & Balance
Encounters Per RestEncounters / Pacing & Variety